Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Worst Enemy Of A Judoka?
JudoForum.com > Judo > Other Martial Arts
Pages: 1, 2
mike323
What martial art would fend off judo the best? other than judo it's self.


say what grappeling would be the best?
what striking?

Mdrnsamurai
No Art. Judo is unbeatable. smile.gif

It all falls on the athlete. If a tree falls in the Forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound?

This question is like that debate. Never ending. Just make sure that you train hard enough when the same question is posed to you in person that you will be able to beat your opponent and answer it yourself.

Train Hard, Stay Safe,
Good Luck

Combat Judo Academy
Serra BJJ
Hanon
QUOTE(mike323 @ Jan 16 2008, 08:29 PM) *
What martial art would fend off judo the best? other than judo it's self.
say what grappeling would be the best?
what striking?


The greatest challenge a judoka ever faces is himself.

Mike
CBJudo
Shooting. sleep.gif
Lily-White
QUOTE(CBJudo @ Jan 16 2008, 04:01 PM) *
Shooting. sleep.gif

Would that be a morote gari? ;) Therefore, your response is wrestling?? :)
Dutch
QUOTE(Hanon @ Jan 16 2008, 09:59 PM) *
The greatest challenge a judoka ever faces is himself.

Mike


Thats what I wanted to post in here. Great minds think alike eh tongue.gif
Sasae
Whatever Chuck Norris does ...
jefmlrjudo
All you can eat buffet.

Spouse who actually wants you to spend time with them and not roll around with 10 sweaty Judoka.

Landlord who actually wants the rent paid



QUOTE(mike323 @ Jan 16 2008, 08:29 PM) *
What martial art would fend off judo the best? other than judo it's self.
say what grappeling would be the best?
what striking?

Matthew Jones
Muay Thai... my face is too pretty to be taking elbows.
sta94
I enthusiastically second what jefmlrjudo said, particularly points #2 and #3. Those are the exact reasons my judo isn't progressing as much as I'd like.
CBJudo
QUOTE(Lily-White @ Jan 17 2008, 10:03 AM) *
Would that be a morote gari? ;) Therefore, your response is wrestling?? :)


No that would be shooting with guns.
Taigyo
Staph infection
ouchie_mata
rifle marksmanship! tongue.gif
Taigyo
QUOTE(Sasae @ Jan 16 2008, 09:37 PM) *
Whatever Chuck Norris does ...

By that you mean really bad movies and mediocre T.V. shows?
Lily-White
Worst enemy of a Judoka?

A sweaty, unwashed gi.
COJudoka
I don't know, If there was no Judo I think I would study San Shou (if there were any clubs around).
Pandaboy
B.O.
Supernova
The scornful look of a woman, when she gazes over at you as you are leaving, saying to you through her eyes "What? You can't spend time with me?!"... ugh!

I was called a judoholic by a former girlfriend of mine, and not in a nice way, like she yelled at me "You're a judoholic,, and like any addiction it's a disease!!" lol!!! Ok, I laughed quietly inside... I broke down and admitted it, after all that's the first step :)
SuperNova
Ga. Nidan
The silent killer. I work with an ex sniper and he makes you want to look over shoulder. roll.gif
der commissar
In mma, the wrestler

In grappling, the bjjer.

Of course I agree with Mike in that it's oneself initially.
Steve Leadbeater
The only way to beat a Judoka is with a .45 acp. 1911A1 Semi Automatoc Pistol loaded with
200 gr. Teflon coated Semi wadcutters out of a Match barrel at >1000fps.

Porvided of course you keep your spacing and do not get to Goshin Jutsu distance.

(worked for me for many years............................retirement is cruel when you are now unarmed, and have to use your learned arts.)
makoto
QUOTE(Sasae @ Jan 16 2008, 09:37 PM) *
Whatever Chuck Norris does ...


That could be because Norris earned a brown belt in Judo before he got into Tang Soo Do. And "Superfoot" Bill Wallace has a Judo black belt, even though he is far better known for his karate experience.
Cichorei Kano
QUOTE(mike323 @ Jan 17 2008, 05:29 AM) *
What martial art would fend off judo the best? other than judo it's self.
say what grappeling would be the best?
what striking?


Your looking too far. Any poorly trained referee suffices to beat even the best judoist. sleep.gif
Kaji
QUOTE(mike323 @ Jan 17 2008, 04:29 AM) *
What martial art would fend off judo the best?
Marital art!And then you have age, disease, injuries, death and taxes. Oh and of course the occasional temptation from the dark side.
QUOTE(Cichorei Kano @ Jan 17 2008, 02:52 PM) *
Your looking to far. Any poorly trained referee suffices to beat even the best judoist. sleep.gif
Reminds me of this joke:http://www.judoinfo.com/humor6.htm (the first joke in the page)
Oztrav
QUOTE(Mdrnsamurai @ Jan 17 2008, 06:40 AM) *
No Art. Judo is unbeatable. smile.gif

It all falls on the athlete. If a tree falls in the Forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound?

This question is like that debate. Never ending. Just make sure that you train hard enough when the same question is posed to you in person that you will be able to beat your opponent and answer it yourself.

Train Hard, Stay Safe,
Good Luck

Combat Judo Academy
Serra BJJ

i really like that answer as well as the staph infection one
Cichorei Kano
QUOTE(Oztrav @ Jan 17 2008, 06:28 PM) *
i really like that answer as well as the staph infection one


You know, sadly there is some truth to it.

Many of the greatest judoist indeed were defeated by disease. Kano, officially by pneumonia. Mifune's mastership of kuzushi and kuki-nage was not able to prevent or stop his throat cancer, Kimura defeated by cancer, Hirano defeated by cancer, half the Kodokan's high-rank women's section was wiped out through cancer (Nihoshi, Sataye, all of them). Often they had some of the most aggressive forms of cancer: lung cancer, liver cancer, the latter one always fatal. Very, very sad, very tragic indeed.
Tranqüilo
I can't think about the worst enemy of a Judoka in this sense (another martial art), but the real worst enemy of a Judoka is laziness.
olafwd
Gun-fu is the one that scares me. Though it's hard to argue against a bad referee ...
johan smits
That would be someone trained in some really old form of koryu jujutsu armed with a tanto.
Close with him/her you get stabbed and cut, judo does not do very well against that.

Happy landings,

Johan Smits
Kurobi
Age got to figure somewhere in there. To some it's impact is felt sooner, some latter. Like some deseases, it slowly but inevitably takes what it wants. Unlike desease however, age will claim us all, it's not selective.

There is a partial remedy though, use every moment spent on the tatami to it's fullest. When age does come, you then can say, what a ride, wouldn't have it anyother way.


Kurobi



Dummy01
Gravity
Taigyo
Ringworm?
carlosgrana
Beer Belly laugh.gif
JiuJitsuJon
QUOTE(makoto @ Jan 17 2008, 12:40 AM) *
That could be because Norris earned a brown belt in Judo before he got into Tang Soo Do. And "Superfoot" Bill Wallace has a Judo black belt, even though he is far better known for his karate experience.


Wasn't aware of that, but Chuck Norris also has a brown belt in BJJ under the Machados.
tis
QUOTE(carlosgrana @ Jan 17 2008, 07:25 PM) *
Beer Belly laugh.gif

biggrin.gif biggrin.gif biggrin.gif

Click to view attachment
This one?
Lived It
Gene Lebell said you use leglocks to beat judo players in his podcast. If anyone would know its him! Anything a man is ignorant of may be used against him so most real combat striking arts would not hurt either. Elbow, knees, headbutts and or any weapons training is helpful against pure grapplers. However once they close you have limited time to strike so be ready to use foul tactics such as biting, groin strikes,striking the back of the head and all sort targets, fishhook etc. A decent sprawl never hurts either.

In the real world I prefer Glock-Fu for life threatening matters and carry a tactical folder also(Kali). For non-life threatening matters idk to fight at all. Im an adult so.....too old for that anymore but if forced I fight very,very dirty. Don't assume judoka only know grappling, anyone in a martial art is liable to wander and learn all sorts of nasty things.

If you fight a judoka its probably something you did anyway we are way to awesome to be ass clowns that start fights!

Cichorei Kano
QUOTE(tis @ Jan 18 2008, 04:21 AM) *


And I thought only Homer Simpson could do that ... dry.gif
liormmm
QUOTE(Cichorei Kano @ Jan 17 2008, 09:12 AM) *
You know, sadly there is some truth to it.

Many of the greatest judoist indeed were defeated by disease. Kano, officially by pneumonia. Mifune's mastership of kuzushi and kuki-nage was not able to prevent or stop his throat cancer, Kimura defeated by cancer, Hirano defeated by cancer, half the Kodokan's high-rank women's section was wiped out through cancer (Nihoshi, Sataye, all of them). Often they had some of the most aggressive forms of cancer: lung cancer, liver cancer, the latter one always fatal. Very, very sad, very tragic indeed.


So one could think that it's better not to reach that level of knowledge in judo as it may bring some sort of cancer or deadly disease?

It's probably like the stigmatas, as you get "closer" to jesus, you are more likely to get them.. or that's how the movie went!
Cichorei Kano
QUOTE(liormmm @ Jan 18 2008, 01:44 PM) *
So one could think that it's better not to reach that level of knowledge in judo as it may bring some sort of cancer or deadly disease?

It's probably like the stigmatas, as you get "closer" to jesus, you are more likely to get them.. or that's how the movie went!



You say. You know what ? I once calculated the time that the 180-some people who ever have been awarded a 9th dan rank by the Kodokan, how long they remained alive after that promotion. I think the average was something like 2-3 years or so. So, there you go. In fact, some people even died on the day they got awarded their 10th dan, which seems to me a very gloomy prospect* ! sleep.gif


(*Yes, I know that such is partly an artifact caused because they really were promoted posthumously, so they were already dead rather than euthanized after the promotion ... although we can never be sure, of course. dry.gif)
forzajudo
QUOTE
Spouse who actually wants you to spend time with them and not roll around with 10 sweaty Judoka.

Landlord who actually wants the rent paid


Amen. laugh.gif
waylander
In my experience, werewolves and vampires are hard to deal with. Try working your sweeps from open guard.
Kaji
QUOTE(waylander @ Jan 18 2008, 02:38 PM) *
In my experience, werewolves and vampires are hard to deal with. Try working your sweeps from open guard.

Don't forget your silver groin cap!
waylander
Haha, I never forget cool.gif
Oztrav
QUOTE(Lived It @ Jan 18 2008, 06:44 AM) *
In the real world I prefer Glock-Fu for life threatening matters and carry a tactical folder also(Kali).
obviously you havent learnt about the success of brazilian glock jitsu all the brazilians are doing it and kicking it in street fights laugh.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif glock fu is so outdated
QUOTE(Cichorei Kano @ Jan 17 2008, 09:12 PM) *
You know, sadly there is some truth to it.Many of the greatest judoist indeed were defeated by disease. Kano, officially by pneumonia. Mifune's mastership of kuzushi and kuki-nage was not able to prevent or stop his throat cancer, Kimura defeated by cancer, Hirano defeated by cancer, half the Kodokan's high-rank women's section was wiped out through cancer (Nihoshi, Sataye, all of them). Often they had some of the most aggressive forms of cancer: lung cancer, liver cancer, the latter one always fatal. Very, very sad, very tragic indeed.
Do you think that there is or was a cancer cluster in the kodokan? Im not sure on judo history and timelines but are those guys all of the same 'era'Did they train to gether were they live in etc
Assasin
A pi***d of Rhino perhaps or a serious injury but more likely to be Yoda from star wars medieval.gif
Judoreturner
The worst enemy of a judoka who is in line for a tournament is the flu. You simply don't feel half as good as you usually are; can hardly breathe, stamina vanishes; you are defeated by the flu, not your opponent.
KBJ2.0
A Jujutsuka who actually Randoris and is a student of violence, because he understands the Judoka's game, and he himself is not "playing" Judo, he is in combat.

That's if this was klife or death with no rules.

BUT ANYTHING CAN HAPPEN and the guy who said "Himself" is right about all martial artisit, not just arts.
Anyone can kill anyone else, but some dont know they have it in them. It changes from day to day as well.
mike323
QUOTE(Oztrav @ Jan 18 2008, 11:05 AM) *
Do you think that there is or was a cancer cluster in the kodokan? Im not sure on judo history and timelines but are those guys all of the same 'era'Did they train to gether were they live in etc


i for some reason have a deep seeded feeling hiroshma has something to do with this.
liormmm
QUOTE(Cichorei Kano @ Jan 18 2008, 02:58 AM) *
You say. You know what ? I once calculated the time that the 180-some people who ever have been awarded a 9th dan rank by the Kodokan, how long they remained alive after that promotion. I think the average was something like 2-3 years or so. So, there you go. In fact, some people even died on the day they got awarded their 10th dan, which seems to me a very gloomy prospect* ! sleep.gif
(*Yes, I know that such is partly an artifact caused because they really were promoted posthumously, so they were already dead rather than euthanized after the promotion ... although we can never be sure, of course. dry.gif)



We should maybe try a field test. Award some healthy 30 - 40 years old a 9th or even a 10th dan rank and see how long they stay alive !
Of course, if we see our test fails (meaning, they stay alive for a long time), we just downgrade them to the rank they were before this test (I was going to say kill them, but some might take it too seriously smile.gif )
Cichorei Kano
QUOTE(liormmm @ Jan 19 2008, 10:08 AM) *
We should maybe try a field test. Award some healthy 30 - 40 years old a 9th or even a 10th dan rank and see how long they stay alive !
Of course, if we see our test fails (meaning, they stay alive for a long time), we just downgrade them to the rank they were before this test (I was going to say kill them, but some might take it too seriously smile.gif )


Look, Phil, I know you played a substantial role in American judo, but ... dry.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.